“People of thieves”, “youpins”, “sexual attacker and Zionist”: the trial on Wednesday of four men, prosecuted for having cyberharassed the host Arthur at the end of 2024, exposed a sample of the hateful anti-Semitism which pours out without restraint on social networks.
For prosecutor Esteban Grandin-Martin, who called for suspended prison sentences of six months to one year, the defendants are “the tree that hides the forest” of the thousands of Internet users participating in this “pack effect”, thinking they are protected by anonymity or the mass of messages.
This wave of cyberharassment targeting him, “it must have been the third”, tells the Paris criminal court Arthur, whose real name is Jacques Essebag, 60, who recounts his “daily hell”.
The first he had to face in the fall of 2023 after an interview where he talked about the Israeli hostages in Gaza after the Hamas attack on October 7.
The hate campaign examined Wednesday was born from a montage of extracts from a show from the 2000s that he hosted, alleging “sexist behavior” towards female candidates.
In December 2024, it triggered a flood of anti-Semitic comments. “Sexual attacker and Zionist go together,” tweets Enzo M., 26, who came to explain himself from his wealthy town in Normandy, looking for a job after a master’s degree in marketing.
A “slightly hot reaction”
“Jews must get out of the audiovisual sector”, says on YouTube Tahar K., 69, who lives alone in his Marseille apartment, ill, prey to depression and heavy alcohol consumption.
In Villiers-le-Bel (Val-d’Oise), Jean-Elie M., 31, unemployed, attacks “these people of disgusting thieves” (sic).
As for Alain R., 77 years old, an Alsatian sympathizer of François Asselineau, a sovereignist regularly accused of conspiracy, he chooses his Telegram account “Plot of the new world order”, to argue that “these yips really get away with anything”.
Four Internet users, strangers to each other, with anonymous lives, who did not immediately understand their arrest in May 2026 and whose defense assures that they were unaware of participating in a harassment campaign.
Pitiful, Enzo M., who tweets mainly about football, rap and video games, speaks of a “slightly hot reaction, alone in (his) corner”. When he attacks the “Zionists”, it is the Israeli government he is angry with, not the Jews, he tries to argue.
This “people” that Jean-Elie M. castigates would no longer refer to the Jews but to “the Caucasians who were going to take black people to enslave them”, assures this thirty-year-old. When Arthur’s lawyer, Jade Dousselin, confronts him with subsequent anti-Semitic tweets, he blurts out: “It was just for fun.”
Alain R., absent for health reasons, invoked the “outlet” of social networks before the investigators. “It’s not mean what I’m saying,” Tahar K., also absent, defended himself. But, he told the police, “the Jews (should) measure their words in the interest of the French.”
“It has to stop”
“Hate rarely begins with an action. It begins with a word, a speech, with what is sometimes presented as a touch of humor,” denounces Me Dousselin. She asks her client: “Are you afraid?”
So Arthur says: when he gets out of the car, he must follow a safety protocol; in restaurants, he never sits against the window; When her 11-year-old daughter goes into the kitchen to drink at night, she walks past one of the “nine armed men” who protect her family.
It is “unbearable” to “explain to my children that armed men have to accompany them to school, just because they are Jewish,” Arthur said. “This is the first time that my Jewishness comes into the prism of people who write to me, who insult me”, “who threaten me”.
Certainly, Arthur explains to AFP, the defendants do not present the profile of potential attackers, but they belong to the “pack” which feeds the algorithms of hatred. “At some point, it has to stop,” he told the court, which will deliver its decision on December 16.