Apple must be tried in June 2027 in Paris, suspected of having organized the planned obsolescence of iPhone models by preventing their owners from repairing them outside official stores, accusations that the American giant “firmly” contests.
These prosecutions of the apple brand for “obstruction of repair and reconditioning”, revealed to AFP from a source close to the matter, are a first, welcomed on Tuesday the association Stop Planned Obsolescence (Hop), which had filed a complaint on December 7, 2022.
“We strongly contest these unfounded allegations,” responded Apple, contacted by AFP, assuring that it “designs durable products, accompanied by software updates that allow users to keep their devices longer.”
Planned obsolescence refers to the techniques used by manufacturers to deliberately reduce the lifespan of their products, usually electronic devices – and thus force consumers to throw away and repurchase more often.
According to the source close to the matter, the American giant is called by the prosecution to appear for four days, starting June 17. He is accused of having prevented repairs on a whole series of models for more than two and a half years, from November 2021 to July 2024.
According to the accusation, the Apple firm configured the software of its smartphones to “make their repair or reconditioning impossible (…) outside of its approved circuits,” said the source close to the case.
Objective: increase sales of Apple’s star product and the turnover of this multinational, which today exceeds 400 billion $ annually – half of which is generated by iPhone sales.
To achieve their goals, Apple engineers are suspected of having ensured that the operating system of its phones “checks the serial number of the components” to deactivate certain features when the iPhones are repaired or changed “outside its official circuit”, according to the source close to the file.
Heavy fine incurred
On certain models, facial recognition (“Face ID”) is for example deactivated if the selfie camera is replaced. The “Health Status” function of the battery could also be affected, according to this source. A whole series of iPhone models are affected: from the iPhone XS to the iPhone 15 Pro Max via the SE 2020 and 2022, or the iPhone 12, 13 and 14.
These processes made both repairs outside the approved circuit and the use of generic parts not bearing the Apple logo impossible, another source said.
Apple risks a heavy fine – up to 300,000 euros, or even a percentage of its annual turnover – and the procedure could allow injured consumers to obtain compensation, this source underlined.
The decision to organize this trial “follows four years of investigation, and reflects the seriousness with which” investigators now take up behavior aimed at unduly limiting the repair and reconditioning of electrical and electronic products, underlined the Hop association.
The very technical investigations had been entrusted to the national investigation service of the Directorate General for Competition, Consumer Affairs and Fraud Control (DGCCRF), the prosecution indicated when the investigation opened in 2023.
Hop recalls that since 2021, in the eyes of French law, the fact for a manufacturer to prevent the repair of its devices “constitutes a specific offense associated with planned obsolescence (…) with the aim of protecting the environment” and consumers.
Before the adoption of this law, in February 2020, Apple had agreed to pay a fine of 25 million euros in France as part of a criminal settlement to put an end to initial prosecutions for deceptive commercial practices.
The Hop association also filed a complaint against the printer manufacturer Epson, for the offense of planned obsolescence and deceptive commercial practices, a case which must be examined on February 25, 2027 at the Nanterre court, she said.
Unlike Apple, in this case it was not a question of repairs being made impossible, but of problems known to consumers for a long time: blocked printing “while the ink contained in the cartridge is not exhausted”, and a “lifespan” reduced “prematurely” for certain components, according to Hop.